The Cost of Labor: To Repair or Replace; That Is the Question
- by Joe Weber - updated on 2/14/2025
When your electronic devices stop working, the decision to repair or replace them can be overwhelming. Both options have benefits and drawbacks, depending on cost, environmental impact, convenience, and device longevity.
In this guide, we'll explain everything you need to know to make an informed decision. Whether it's your smartphone, tablet, or laptop, understanding when to repair rather than replace can save you money, minimize environmental waste, and help you get the most out of your devices.
Cost Considerations
One of the first things to consider is the cost. In most cases, repairing your device is significantly cheaper than buying a brand-new replacement. For example, battery and screen replacements often start as low as around $70.00, making repairs a budget-friendly solution.
On the other hand, replacing it could cost hundreds—or even thousands—of dollars depending on the model and type of device. Additionally, repairing eliminates the need for expensive insurance plans, saving you even more in the long run.
Environmental Impact
Repairing instead of replacing your devices is also a great way to reduce your carbon footprint. Electronic waste (e-waste) is a growing environmental concern, with millions of tons discarded each year.
Repairing extends the lifespan of your devices, reducing the demand for new electronics and the resources required to manufacture them. It's an eco-friendly choice that benefits both you and the planet.
Want to know what items we recycle at Batteries Plus? Check out our recycling services page for all the details.
Convenience and Data Preservation
Repairing your device can often be faster and more convenient than buying and setting up a new one. Local repair shops, like Batteries Plus, frequently offer free diagnostics and same-day service with no appointment necessary.
More importantly, repairing your current device means you don't have to worry about transferring your personal data, such as photos, contacts, apps, and even banking information to a new device—saving you both time and effort.
Quality of Repairs
The quality of your repair is just as important as deciding to repair in the first place. Choosing a reputable repair service ensures your device is fixed correctly and safely using high-quality parts.
At Batteries Plus, many of our locations are part of both the Apple Independent Repair Provider (IRP) program and the Samsung Independent Service Provider (ISP) program. This means repairs are performed with genuine manufacturer parts by trained professionals. Some of our most popular repairs include the Apple iPhone 12, iPhone 13, iPhone 14, Samsung Galaxy S21, Galaxy S22 Ultra, and Galaxy S23 Ultra, among others.
Additionally, our repair technicians are WISE-certified, guaranteeing the highest standards of expertise. We also back every repair with a six-month nationwide warranty on parts and labor, giving you peace of mind that your device is in trusted hands. Whether it's a cracked screen, a failing battery, or another issue, you can trust us to help restore your device to peak performance.
Making the Decision
To make the best decision, consider these key factors:
- Cost Comparison: If repair costs are less than 50% of what it would cost to replace the device, repairing is usually the smarter choice.
- Age of the Device: Older devices (typically over 10 years) may be better candidates for replacement, as repairs could become a recurring expense.
- Performance Needs: If your device no longer meets your needs—whether it's slow processing speed or outdated technology—replacing it might be worth the investment.
- Warranty Options: Repair warranties, like those offered by Batteries Plus, can provide additional reassurance when opting for repairs.
Protect Your Investment: Cases and Screen Protectors
Once your phone is repaired, it's important to prevent future damage. Adding a high-quality phone case and screen protector can go a long way in safeguarding your device from accidental drops, scratches, and other mishaps.
- Phone Cases: A durable case can absorb shock and protect your phone's edges and back from cracks and dents. Look for cases with drop-protection ratings for added peace of mind.
- Screen Protectors: Tempered glass or film screen protectors act as a barrier, shielding your screen from scratches and cracks without affecting touch sensitivity.
A small investment in protective accessories like cases and screen protectors can significantly extend the lifespan of your device and help you avoid expensive repairs in the future. Don't forget to inquire about these options during your repair visit—they're a simple way to keep your phone safe and secure.
Batteries Plus carries a variety of options tailored to your device. It's a simple way to protect your investment and keep your phone looking and working like new.
Making the Smart Choice for Your Devices
Deciding whether to repair or replace your device doesn't have to be complicated. By weighing the cost, environmental impact, and your personal needs, you can make a choice that aligns with both your budget and your values. Repairing is often the more affordable and eco-friendly option, especially when done by trusted professionals.
The next time you're faced with this decision, take a step back and consider all the factors—your wallet, your data, and even the planet will thank you.
If you're ready to repair your device, visit our repair services page for more information, or stop by your nearest Batteries Plus location to speak with our certified technicians. We're here to help you get back to what matters most!